Skip to content

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.

Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Melissa lohmier

Melissa lohmier

May 4, 2024

5  out of  5 rating by Melissa lohmier
"Shelly is wonderful! Helped me switch everything over to State Farm flawlessly! Everyone in her office is also so friendly and helpful."
Profile photo of Daniel McClintock

Daniel McClintock

May 3, 2024

5  out of  5 rating by Daniel McClintock
"Mary Cath and Her amazing team are the best you can get in the Pittsburgh area! Any time you need honest guidance, they are there to help. My family and I would never go anywhere else. We’re Statefarm lifers! Keep up the great work!"
Profile photo of Aaron Gilligan

Aaron Gilligan

January 31, 2024

5  out of  5 rating by Aaron Gilligan
"This office and staff are the best! Very efficient, responsive , and a delight to deal with. They make you feel like you’re their only customer with the attention they provide. We have 3 cars and our home insurance covered with this office."
Profile photo of S. F.

S. F.

January 6, 2024

5  out of  5 rating by S. F.
"Always pleasant and helpful! Never had an issue in all my time with them."
Profile photo of Ryno Asphalt

Ryno Asphalt

November 28, 2022

1  out of  5 rating by Ryno Asphalt
"Guy in the office can't even get my declaration page to my credit union. I've been calling for 2 weeks straight now"
Profile photo of Anna Fisher

Anna Fisher

October 17, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Anna Fisher
"I have been with this agency for over 20 years and have never once thought about switching! Mary Cath, Shelly, and Dave are simply the best! Any time I ever have a question, I am greeted so kindly and professionally. Highly Recommend!"
Profile photo of Deborah Devine

Deborah Devine

October 12, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Deborah Devine
"We have been with Mary Cath for over 30 years. No complaints. She and her staff are always there with an answer should we need one. 1st class!!"
Profile photo of Emily Papathanasiou

Emily Papathanasiou

October 12, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Emily Papathanasiou
"Incredible customer service! Friendly, efficient, and found us the best rates! Highly recommend!!"
Profile photo of Daniel Gerhart

Daniel Gerhart

October 12, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Daniel Gerhart
"Shelly and her crew go above and beyond to make sure my family and friends are covered at the best possible rate out there. Also anytime I have a question or problem Shelly is always there quickly."
Profile photo of Tyler Miller

Tyler Miller

October 12, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Tyler Miller
"Awesome customer service. Very helpful and nice."
Profile photo of Jan S

Jan S

February 24, 2022

1  out of  5 rating by Jan S
"She is never there and the guy in the office is useless . Terrible service puts people at risk."
Profile photo of Jane Mowrer

Jane Mowrer

October 9, 2020

5  out of  5 rating by Jane Mowrer
"I have had a wonderful experience with this State Farm agency. Mary Cath, Machelle, & John are the most professional and friendly people I have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. I always get a human being when I call not a recording saying press 1 press 4 then you stay on hold forever. They are all so caring ... I had a minor accident and I was overwhelmed with their concern for me and how they could help me. The claim was settled so fast and so professional. When I swithched from Progressive to State Farm I saved money and had the same coverage. I also like to know that I am supporting a locally owned business. It's a win-win Mary Cath is an independent agent and she is backed by one of the largest Insurance/Financial Companies in the United States. Mary Cath took so much time to help my husband and I understand the difference between life insurance policies. She took time to help us with all of our insurance needs AND financial advice for the future of our children and our retirement. Most people ( including ourselves) don't think about the fact that the life insurance that you get through your job ENDS when you retire. They helped us realize that we should get life insurance at a younger age and NOT wait until after retirement. The best thing we ever did ( insurance wise) was to take the time to do an insurance review with Mary Cath. She helped us plan for the future to protect our property, our finances, ourselves, and most importantly our children. Thanks to all the people at Mary Cath Herforth's State Farm Insurance Company. You all really changed the way that my husband and I feel about insurance and Insurance Companies."
Profile photo of Anne Fisher

Anne Fisher

October 3, 2020

5  out of  5 rating by Anne Fisher
"I have been with Mary Cath since I got my first car over 35 years ago. Impeccable service over the years we added home, life, and even loan and banking accounts. I feel like they are family, Mary Cath, Michelle, and John are so helpful. They are really good at explaining my options. Thank you for making insurance and loan/ bank accounts easy!"
Profile photo of Robyn Jendeski

Robyn Jendeski

October 3, 2020

5  out of  5 rating by Robyn Jendeski
"Every single time I call with a question, I am greeted with the utmost pleasant and friendly representative, Machelle Herforth or Marycath Herforth to clearly explain the answer to my question. I’ve been a long time customer and will never even consider shopping around. Why look, when you already have the best!"
Profile photo of Lori Stumpf

Lori Stumpf

October 1, 2020

5  out of  5 rating by Lori Stumpf
"Mary Cath and her team provide an excellent experience when reviewing and suggesting new products as well as when assisting with existing services."
Profile photo of Katherine Plance

Katherine Plance

October 1, 2020

5  out of  5 rating by Katherine Plance
"Wonderful team! Always finding ways to save the customer money. I highly recommend!"
Profile photo of Stephen Millender

Stephen Millender

November 22, 2019

5  out of  5 rating by Stephen Millender
"She is great and has a great supporting staff as well. Everyone's always eager to help you with whatever your needs are. I've been her customer for about 3 years and refuse to go elsewhere."